The Toronto Blue Jays have scored a record-breaking 23 runs in the first two games of the ALDS, giving bettors plenty to consider heading into Game 3. With the Yankees fighting for survival at home, there are strong betting angles to explore in this elimination matchup. In our Blue Jays vs. Yankees Predictions, we’ll break down the best bets, parlays, and player props to consider for this critical MLB playoffs clash.
Toronto’s bats are red-hot, led by Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Daulton Varsho, while New York will look to Carlos Rodón to steady their pitching staff after two disastrous outings. Below, we’ve put together our best bets for Blue Jays vs. Yankees Game 3.
*Note: Sports betting is unpredictable. These are suggestions based on analysis, but outcomes can vary.
Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees MLB Division Series Game 3 Match Overview
The Yankees enter Game 3 in a must-win scenario after being outscored 23-8 in the first two games. Their rotation has been shaky, with starters failing to last past three innings in either outing. Carlos Rodón, their Game 3 starter, is tasked with eating innings to preserve a bullpen already showing signs of fatigue. Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, and Giancarlo Stanton headline the lineup, but Judge has struggled mightily against Shane Bieber, striking out in more than half of his career at-bats against the Blue Jays’ Game 3 starter.
Meanwhile, the Blue Jays’ offense is firing on all cylinders. Guerrero Jr. is 6-for-9 with two home runs in the series, while Varsho added two homers and two doubles in Game 2. Even without Bo Bichette, Toronto has proven its depth, with Andrés Giménez stepping up defensively at shortstop. Their confidence is high, and with Bieber leading the rotation, the Jays are poised to close out the series and advance to the ALCS.
Blue Jays +1.5 Runs
Backing Toronto on the run line feels safe given their current momentum. They’ve won the first two games by wide margins and continue to get production throughout their lineup. With Rodón’s struggles against the Blue Jays (.752 OPS allowed), Toronto should be able to keep this game within reach at worst, if not secure the outright win.
Total Runs Over 7.5
Both teams have shown they can put runs on the board, and bullpen fatigue on the Yankees’ side adds to the likelihood of another high-scoring affair. Toronto’s offense has already hit more home runs than strikeouts in the series, and New York’s power bats remain dangerous in their home park. Given the trends, the over on 7.5 looks favorable.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. To Record 2+ Total Bases
Guerrero is in peak form, recording multi-hit games and already notching a grand slam in this series. His ability to hit for both contact and power makes him a strong candidate to clear two total bases, whether through extra-base hits or multiple singles.
Ryan McMahon to Record a Hit
This is the higher-risk prop from our picks, but McMahon has been consistent at the plate and brings balance to Toronto’s lineup. Even a single would cash this bet, and given the Yankees’ pitching issues, he has a good chance to contribute.
Use Playbook to Make MLB Division Series Game 3 Picks
Action Network’s Playbook AI bot is a new tool that can help simplify your betting. If you see a Blue Jays vs. Yankees pick on X or Discord, just tag @Playbook and it will instantly generate a betslip you can use. It’s a quick way to turn betting discussions into actionable wagers without missing a beat.
- SCCG Management. The Gambling Industry’s Global Connector. Access Here.
- Source: https://sportshandle.com/blue-jays-vs-yankees-predictions-best-bets-mlb-division-series-player-props/